Luckily there's an option at every price point. The Sam & Libby Eliza Booties are from Target but look great and are a steal at $36, while the Sam Edelman Petty Booties (currently 25% off in Shopbop's Friends and Family sale through October 15!) are a good mid price point option. I also love the Nico Boot from Madewell, which is still a bit of a splurge but a great casual bootie option and one you'd likely wear again and again.
Splurge: Kate Spade Terri Booties
Spend: Sam Edelman Petty Booties